diff --git a/app/Http/Controllers/TenderController.php b/app/Http/Controllers/TenderController.php
index 09bad66..8b0571f 100644
--- a/app/Http/Controllers/TenderController.php
+++ b/app/Http/Controllers/TenderController.php
@@ -700,15 +700,17 @@ class TenderController extends Controller
         $kjpps = KJPP::whereIn('id', $detail_penawaran)
             ->get()
             ->map(function ($item) {
-                $emails = [$item->email_kantor];
+                $emails = collect(explode(',', $item->email_kantor))->filter()->unique();
 
                 // Parse JSON string jika ada dan tidak kosong
                 if (!empty($item->detail_email_kantor) && $item->detail_email_kantor !== '[]') {
                     $detail_emails = json_decode($item->detail_email_kantor, true);
                     if (is_array($detail_emails)) {
                         foreach ($detail_emails as $detail) {
-                            if (isset($detail['email_kantor'])) {
-                                $emails[] = $detail['email_kantor'];
+                            if (is_array($detail) && isset($detail['email_kantor'])) {
+                                $emails->push($detail['email_kantor']);
+                            } elseif (is_string($detail)) {
+                                $emails->push($detail);
                             }
                         }
                     }
@@ -716,10 +718,11 @@ class TenderController extends Controller
 
                 return [
                     'kjpp' => $item,
-                    'emails' => array_filter($emails)
+                    'emails' => array_filter($emails->unique()->values()->all())
                 ];
             });
 
+
         foreach ($permohonan->documents as $document) {
             $village_permohonan = $document->village_code;
             $district_permohonan = $document->district_code;
@@ -894,26 +897,30 @@ class TenderController extends Controller
 
         $detail_penawaran = PenawaranDetailTender::with('kjpp')->where('kjpp_rekanan_id', '=', $id)->pluck('kjpp_rekanan_id')->toArray();
         $kjpps = KJPP::whereIn('id', $detail_penawaran)
-            ->get()
-            ->map(function ($item) {
-                $emails = [$item->email_kantor];
+                     ->get()
+                     ->map(function ($item) {
+                         $emails = collect(explode(',', $item->email_kantor))->filter()->unique();
 
-                // Parse JSON string jika ada dan tidak kosong
-                if (!empty($item->detail_email_kantor) && $item->detail_email_kantor !== '[]') {
-                    $detail_emails = json_decode($item->detail_email_kantor, true);
-                    if (is_array($detail_emails)) {
-                        foreach ($detail_emails as $detail) {
-                            if (isset($detail['email_kantor'])) {
-                                $emails[] = $detail['email_kantor'];
-                            }
-                        }
-                    }
-                }
+                         // Parse JSON string jika ada dan tidak kosong
+                         if (!empty($item->detail_email_kantor) && $item->detail_email_kantor !== '[]') {
+                             $detail_emails = json_decode($item->detail_email_kantor, true);
+                             if (is_array($detail_emails)) {
+                                 foreach ($detail_emails as $detail) {
+                                     if (is_array($detail) && isset($detail['email_kantor'])) {
+                                         $emails->add($detail['email_kantor']);
+                                     } elseif (is_string($detail)) {
+                                         $emails->add($detail);
+                                     }
+                                 }
+                             }
+                         }
 
-                return array_filter($emails);
-            })
-            ->flatten()
-            ->toArray();
+                         return array_filter(array_values(iterator_to_array($emails)));
+                     })
+                     ->flatten()
+                     ->unique()
+                     ->values()
+                     ->toArray();
 
         $dp1 = PenawaranDetailTender::with('kjpp')->where('kjpp_rekanan_id', '=', $id)->first();