diff --git a/resources/views/penilai/components/signature-approval.blade.php b/resources/views/penilai/components/signature-approval.blade.php
index f71d05c..fc8cec2 100644
--- a/resources/views/penilai/components/signature-approval.blade.php
+++ b/resources/views/penilai/components/signature-approval.blade.php
@@ -2,20 +2,28 @@
             @php
                 use Modules\Usermanagement\Models\User;
 
-                $penilaiUser = User::where('id', $penilai->userPenilaiTeam->id)->first();
-                $imagePathPenilai = storage_path(
-                    'app/public/signatures/' . $penilaiUser->id . '/' . $penilaiUser->sign,
-                );
+                $penilaiUser = isset($penilai->userPenilaiTeam) ? $penilai->userPenilaiTeam : null;
+                $imagePathPenilai = $penilaiUser && $penilaiUser->sign
+                    ? storage_path('app/public/signatures/' . $penilaiUser->id . '/' . $penilaiUser->sign)
+                    : null;
+
+                $soUser = $permohonan->approval_so ? User::find($permohonan->approval_so) : null;
+                $imagePathSo = $soUser && $soUser->sign
+                    ? storage_path('app/public/signatures/' . $soUser->id . '/' . $soUser->sign)
+                    : null;
+
+                $eoUser = $permohonan->approval_eo ? User::find($permohonan->approval_eo) : null;
+                $imagePathEO = $eoUser && $eoUser->sign
+                    ? storage_path('app/public/signatures/' . $eoUser->id . '/' . $eoUser->sign)
+                    : null;
+
+
+                $ddUser = $permohonan->approval_dd ? User::find($permohonan->approval_dd) : null;
+                $imagePathDD = $ddUser && $ddUser->sign
+                    ? storage_path('app/public/signatures/' . $ddUser->id . '/' . $ddUser->sign)
+                    : null;
 
-                $soUser = User::where('id', $senior_officer->id)->first();
-                $imagePathSo = storage_path('app/public/signatures/' . $soUser->id . '/' . $soUser->sign);
 
-                $imagePathEO = storage_path(
-                    'app/public/signatures/' .
-                        User::role('EO Appraisal')->first()->id .
-                        '/' .
-                        User::role('EO Appraisal')->first()->sign,
-                );
 
                 $imagePathDD = storage_path(
                     'app/public/signatures/' .