diff --git a/resources/views/penilai/index.blade.php b/resources/views/penilai/index.blade.php
index 8fe2fbb..3728b84 100644
--- a/resources/views/penilai/index.blade.php
+++ b/resources/views/penilai/index.blade.php
@@ -139,31 +139,31 @@
                 debitur_id: {
                     title: 'Debitur',
                     render: (item, data) => {
-                        return `${data.debiture.name}`;
+                        return data.debiture && data.debiture.name ? `${data.debiture.name}` : '-';
                     },
                 },
                 branch_id: {
                     title: 'Cabang Pemohon',
                     render: (item, data) => {
-                        return `${data.branch.name}`;
+                        return data.branch && data.branch.name ? `${data.branch.name}` : '-';
                     },
                 },
                 user_id: {
                     title: 'User Pemohon',
                     render: (item, data) => {
-                        return `${data.user.name}`;
+                        return data.user && data.user.name ? `${data.user.name}` : '-';
                     },
                 },
                 tujuan_penilaian_id: {
                     title: 'Tujuan Penilaian',
                     render: (item, data) => {
-                        return `${data.tujuan_penilaian.name}`;
+                        return data.tujuan_penilaian && data.tujuan_penilaian.name ? `${data.tujuan_penilaian.name}` : '-';
                     },
                 },
                 jenis_fasilitas_kredit_id: {
                     title: 'Fasilitas Kredit',
                     render: (item, data) => {
-                        return `${data.jenisfasilitas_kredit.name}`;
+                        return data.jenisfasilitas_kredit && data.jenisfasilitas_kredit.name ? `${data.jenisfasilitas_kredit.name}` : '-';
                     },
                 },
                 tanggal_survei: {