diff --git a/Http/Controllers/ReportController.php b/Http/Controllers/ReportController.php
index ed50a66..67e4d89 100644
--- a/Http/Controllers/ReportController.php
+++ b/Http/Controllers/ReportController.php
@@ -73,7 +73,7 @@
                                      ->where('tanggal_hapus_buku', '<=', request()->get('start_date'))
                                      ->whereRelation('debitur', 'name', 'like', '%' . request()->get('debitur') . '%')
                                      ->where('detail_pembayaran.deleted_at', null)
-                                     ->groupBy('detail_pembayaran.tanggal_pembayaran')
+                                     ->groupBy('hapus_buku.nomor_pinjaman', 'detail_pembayaran.tanggal_pembayaran')
                                      ->get();
                 } else {
                     $data = HapusBuku::with([
@@ -89,7 +89,7 @@
                                      ->where('kode_cabang', request()->get('kode_cabang'))
                                      ->whereRelation('debitur', 'name', 'like', '%' . request()->get('debitur') . '%')
                                      ->where('detail_pembayaran.deleted_at', null)
-                                     ->groupBy('detail_pembayaran.tanggal_pembayaran')
+                                     ->groupBy('hapus_buku.nomor_pinjaman', 'detail_pembayaran.tanggal_pembayaran')
                                      ->get();
                 }
 
@@ -237,7 +237,7 @@
                                      ->where('detail_penagihan.deleted_at', null)
                                      ->where('detail_pembayaran.deleted_at', null)
                                      ->where('detail_jaminan.deleted_at', null)
-                                     ->groupBy('detail_penagihan.pic_penagihan', 'detail_penagihan.tanggal_penagihan')
+                                     ->groupBy('hapus_buku.nomor_pinjaman', 'detail_penagihan.pic_penagihan', 'detail_penagihan.tanggal_penagihan')
                                      ->get();
                 } else {
                     $data = HapusBuku::with([
@@ -258,7 +258,7 @@
                                      ->where('detail_penagihan.deleted_at', null)
                                      ->where('detail_pembayaran.deleted_at', null)
                                      ->where('detail_jaminan.deleted_at', null)
-                                     ->groupBy('detail_penagihan.pic_penagihan', 'detail_penagihan.tanggal_penagihan')
+                                     ->groupBy('hapus_buku.nomor_pinjaman', 'detail_penagihan.pic_penagihan', 'detail_penagihan.tanggal_penagihan')
                                      ->get();
                 }